Innovative Research-Based Educational Tools/Resources to Improve the Breast Cancer Screening Experience for Women With Disabilities

August 2012 Vol 3, No 4
Linda Muraca, RN, MN
Mount Sinai Hospital
M. Bianca Seaton, MSc, PhD(c)
Mount Sinai Hospital
Mary Agnes Beduz, RN, MN, PhD
Mount Sinai Hospital
Julie Devaney, MA
Mount Sinai Hospital
Jan Angus, RN, MN, PhD
Faculty of Nursing, University of Toronto
Nancy Barry, BA
Centre for Independent Living
Samira Chandani
Cancer Support Network
Laura McDonald, BASc
Toronto Central LIHN
Fran Odette, MSW
Springtide Resources. All, Toronto, Canada

Background: Women with disabilities (WWD) have the same biological risk of developing breast cancer as nondisabled women but are less likely to participate in regular cancer screening. A previous community-based needs assessment conducted by our research team in Ontario, Canada, consented 24 WWD in 4 urban- and 1 suburban-situated focus groups to learn about their experiences with facilitators and barriers to cancer screening. The WWD shared stories of dehumanizing experiences with healthcare providers (HPs), stressing that negative encounters were powerful deterrents to a return screening. A key recommendation from the WWD was to provide best-practice educational opportunities for HPs about how to create enabling screening environments.

Methods: Our research team subsequently conducted focus groups with 43 mammography technologists, radiologists, and reception staff from 3 academic teaching hospitals in Ontario, Canada, to learn about their attitudes, experiences, and learning needs when working with WWD. Data were analyzed using qualitative content analysis. The focus group participants demonstrated a strong desire to provide a positive screening experience for all patients but had a tendency to respond to novel or unusual care situations involving WWD with social awkwardness or confused inaction. These findings underscore the need for greater disability awareness among HPs working in cancer screening.

Results: Merging the results of the 2 focus group studies with HPs and WWD, our team has developed creative, evidence-based educational tools and resources about how to create enabling screening environments. First, we developed an immersive learning program for HPs using standardized patients trained to role-play breast imaging scenarios. This highly effective method of education with breast imaging staff from the 3 teaching hospitals was successful in positively shifting intention to change behaviors with WWD, and participant satisfaction was very high. Subsequently, we developed e-learning modules, an educational film, tip sheets for WWD and HPs, and an accessible Web-based facilitation manual for use at other screening centers.

Conclusion: These educational tools and resources enable other screening centers to train their staff about respectful communication with WWD and improve future screening attendance. The research results from our 2 studies as well as these innovative tools and resources will be shared in this presentation.

Related Items

Supporting Young Patients With Breast Cancer
By Zeena Nackerdien, PhD
December 2025 Vol 16, No 12
Explore the unique challenges faced by young patients with breast cancer and learn how innovative navigation programs are bridging gaps in care and empowering patients to thrive.
Identification and Treatment of Patients With Hormone Receptor–Positive, HER2-Negative Early Breast Cancer at High Risk of Recurrence: monarchE Study Long-Term Outcomes
Special Issues and Supplements
We are pleased to announce the release of our next issue of Clinical Trials to Clinical Practice. This article provides expert commentary from Joyce A. O’Shaughnessy, MD, on the use of endocrine therapy with or without adjuvant abemaciclib for patients with high-risk, hormone receptor (HR)-positive, HER2-negative early breast cancer.
Category I: Community Outreach/Prevention
October 2024 Vol 15, No 10
Navigation tactics include community needs assessments and education on early signs of cancer, screening guidelines, and community and state resources to support patient populations.
Journal of Oncology Navigation & Survivorship
JONS

Subscribe Today!

To sign up for our print publication or e-newsletter, please enter your contact information below.

I'd like to receive:

  • First Name *
    Last Name *
     
    Profession or Role
    Primary Specialty or Disease State
    Country